Comfortmaker Heat Pump Reviews: Is This Budget Brand Worth It?

Josh Mitchell

Written By

Josh Mitchell

Expert Reviewed By

Holly Curell

Last Updated On

“If you make a purchase using our provided links, we may receive a commission. Learn more here.

Quick Guide - Comfortmaker

My Opinion

For those with moderate summers and winters, Comfortmaker is a good brand to look at for heat pumps. Their top-of-the-line models feature advanced technology comparable to bigger brands. However, many HVAC technicians find their systems more difficult to install. 

3.9

Overall Score


Reliability

3.75

Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress

Performance

3.8

Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress

Energy Efficiency

4.0

Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress

Warranty

4.3

Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress

Value for Money

3.75

Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Current Progress
Pros
  • High efficiency
  • Advanced technology
  • Durability
  • Quiet operation
  • Warranty
CONS
  • Cost
  • Limited availability
  • Complex installation
  • Variable performance in extreme climates

Comfortmaker, with its reputation for durable and efficient systems, is one of the more intriguing options for homeowners.

It’s reputed to be durable and efficient, so I spent time researching them and talking to homeowners who use Comfortmaker heat pumps.

Here’s a TLDR version of Comfortmaker heat pumps.

Quick Guide To Comfortmaker Heat Pumps

Best Overall Model

Ion Variable-Speed Heat Pump (CVH8)


This premium model is the epitome of efficiency and advanced technology. With up to 18.5 SEER2 cooling efficiency and 9 HSPF2 heating efficiency, it offers superior comfort and energy savings. Its variable-speed system adapts to changing conditions, ensuring consistent comfort and lower energy bills.

Good Value Model

Performance Heat Pump (N4H5S)


The Comfortmaker Performance Heat Pump is an economical choice that doesn't compromise quality. It's Energy Star qualified in select sizes, offering up to 15.2 SEER2 cooling efficiency and 8.1 HSPF2 heating efficiency. I recommend this model for budget-conscious homeowners who still want reliable and efficient performance.

Avoid This Model

Performance Coastal Heat Pump (N4H5S**C)


While this model is designed for coastal environments and offers protection against corrosion, it has the same efficiency ratings (up to 15.2 SEER2 / 12.5 EER2 cooling and 8.1 HSPF2 heating efficiency) as the standard Performance Heat Pump (N4H5S).

If you're not in a coastal area, the additional features for corrosion resistance might not justify any extra cost compared to the standard model. Additionally, its sound level is as low as 69 decibels, which is not the quietest option.

As someone who has spent years in the HVAC field, I've developed a deep understanding of what makes a heat pump stand out in terms of performance and reliability.

Here, I'll provide my thorough analysis of the Comfortmaker heat pump brand that will guide you in choosing the right heating solution for your home.

Stay tuned and explore the intricacies of Comfortmaker's technology and discover what sets these heat pumps apart in the market.

Comfortmaker Heat Pump Review – My Honest Opinion

Here’s everything I did and didn’t like about Comfortmaker heating systems.

Pros And Cons Of Buying A Comfortmaker Heat Pump

THE GOOD
  • High efficiency: With SEER ratings ranging from 15.2 to 18.5 SEER2 and HSPF ratings from 8.2 to 11 HSPF2, Comfortmaker heat pumps offer excellent energy efficiency for less power spent.
  • Advanced technology: Many models come with variable-speed and two-stage compressors, providing precise temperature control, enhanced comfort, and further energy savings.
  • Durability: Comfortmaker units are built to last, featuring robust construction and reliable performance. This durability is a significant advantage for long-term use.
  • Quiet operation: Designed for low noise levels, these heat pumps operate quietly, ensuring a peaceful home environment.
  • Warranty: Comfortmaker offers strong warranty terms, reflecting confidence in their products' longevity and performance.
THE BAD
  • Cost: Comfortmaker heat pumps are generally in the mid to high price range. This might be a barrier for budget-conscious consumers.
  • Limited availability: Depending on the region, Comfortmaker products might not be as readily available as some other brands, potentially leading to challenges in purchasing or servicing.
  • Complex installation: Some models, especially those with advanced features, may
  • Variable performance in extreme climates: While efficient in moderate climates, some models might not perform as well in extreme winter or hot weather.

How Much Do They Cost?

Pricing by Model & Size

The cost of Comfortmaker heat pumps varies depending on the specific model and the capacity of the unit, which is usually measured in tons.

A larger capacity unit, suitable for a bigger home, will generally cost more than a smaller unit.

Here's a summarized table to give you an idea:

Model Series

Capacity (Tons)

Estimated Price Range

Ion Series (CVH8, C4H7T, C4H5S)

1.5 - 2

$3,500 - $5,000

 

2.5 - 3

$4,000 - $5,500

 

3.5 - 5

$4,500 - $6,500

Performance Series (N4H7T, N4H5S)

1.5 - 2

$2,500 - $3,500

 

2.5 - 3

$3,000 - $4,000

 

3.5 - 5

$3,500 - $4,500

QuietComfort Series (DLCURA)

2 - 5

$3,000 - $5,000

Model Series

Capacity (Tons)

Estimated Price Range

Ion Series (CVH8, C4H7T, C4H5S)

1.5 - 2

$3,500 - $5,000

Ion Series (CVH8, C4H7T, C4H5S)

2.5 - 3

$4,000 - $5,500

Ion Series (CVH8, C4H7T, C4H5S)

3.5 - 5

$4,500 - $6,500

Performance Series (N4H7T, N4H5S)

1.5 - 2

$2,500 - $3,500

Performance Series (N4H7T, N4H5S)

2.5 - 3

$3,000 - $4,000

Performance Series (N4H7T, N4H5S)

3.5 - 5

$3,500 - $4,500

QuietComfort Series (DLCURA)

2 - 5

$3,000 - $5,000

*ACLAB Note: These prices are approximate and can vary based on factors like installation complexity, local labor rates, and additional components needed.

TL;DR: Depending upon the model and size you choose, Comfortmaker can range anywhere between $2,500 - $5,000 without installation. Comfortmaker isn't the cheapest brand in the budget market segment.

Cost Variation Across US States

The cost of installing a Comfortmaker heat pump can also vary by location due to differences in labor costs, demand, and even climate.

Here's a general idea of how costs can vary across different states:

  • Northeastern States:
    $3,500 - $6,500. Installation costs can be higher due to the complexity of integrating with existing heating systems.
  • Southern States:
    $3,000 - $6,000. Prices might be lower due to the high demand and prevalence of heat pump installations.
  • Midwestern States:
    $3,000 - $5,500. Costs can vary widely, with rural areas potentially having lower prices than urban centers.
  • Western States:
    $3,500 - $7,000. Prices in coastal areas, especially in California, tend to be higher, while inland states may have more moderate costs.

ACLAB Note:

These figures are general estimates. For the most accurate pricing, get quotes from local HVAC contractors who can assess the specific needs of your home and provide a detailed cost breakdown.

Model

Ton

Home Size

Cost (Unit Only)

Cost + Install

CVH8

2 - 5

1200 – 3200 sq. ft.

$3500 – $5000

$6000 – $8500

C4H7T

2 - 5

800 – 3000 sq. ft.

$3500 – $5000

$5450 – $8200

C4H5S

1.5 – 5

600 – 3000 sq. ft.

$2500 – $3500

$5450 – $8200

DLCURA

2 - 5

600 – 3000 sq. ft.

$2000 – $2500

$5200 – $8000

N4H7T

2 - 5

800 – 3000 sq. ft.

$3000 - $5000

$5000 - $7000

N4H5S/N4H5S***C

1.5 - 5

600 – 3000 sq. ft.

$2500 - $4500

$4500 - $6000

TL;DR: Depending upon your location in U.S, the cost of procuring and installing a heat pump can vary.


What Makes Comfortmaker Heat Pumps Stand Out?

Comfortmaker Heat Pumps stand out due to several key features that enhance their performance, durability, and user experience.

Post Painted Fin Stock and Coated Wire Grille

The post-painted fin stock enhances the unit's resistance to environmental elements like rain, snow, and UV radiation.

This feature ensures that the heat pump maintains its efficiency and performance over time, even in harsh weather conditions.

The coated wire grille adds an extra layer of protection against physical damage and corrosion, prolonging the unit's lifespan and maintaining its aesthetic appeal.

Scroll Compressor

Scroll compressors are known for their efficiency and quieter operation compared to traditional piston compressors.

They have fewer moving parts, which means less wear and tear and a lower likelihood of mechanical failure.

This type of compressor is also known for providing consistent temperature control and operating more smoothly, which can lead to energy savings and enhanced comfort in your home.

Extra-Thick Shell Compressor House

The extra-thick shell around the compressor acts as a robust shield, protecting this crucial component from external impacts and environmental factors.

This housing ensures that the compressor operates in an optimal environment, free from dust, debris, and moisture, which can significantly extend its operational life and maintain its efficiency.

Top Discharge Design

The top discharge design is strategic in managing the airflow and heat dispersion.

Directing hot air upwards and away from the unit helps maintain the efficiency of the heat pump and reduces the risk of recirculating hot air.

This design also contributes to a reduction in noise levels, making the operation of the heat pump less intrusive in a residential setting.

Durable Copper Tubing and Aluminum Fin Coil

Copper tubing and aluminum fins are used in the heat pump's coil due to their excellent thermal conductivity.

Copper tubing efficiently transfers heat, making the heating and cooling processes more effective.

Aluminum fins, being lightweight and corrosion-resistant, complement the copper tubing by enhancing the overall heat exchange process.

This combination ensures optimal performance and durability of the heat pump.

Integrated Solid-State Controls

These controls represent the latest in HVAC technology, offering precise and responsive temperature management.

Integrated solid-state controls allow easier and more accurate adjustments of the heat pump's settings, ensuring optimal comfort levels.

They also enable advanced features like programmable schedules, remote access, and diagnostics, improving the user experience and potentially saving energy.

TL;DR: Being a budget brand, Comfortmaker does not have the most advanced set of features. It does, however, puts effort in including features that can make their units as durable as possible.


How Energy Efficient Are They?

The energy efficiency of a heat pump is typically measured by two key metrics: the Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) and the Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF). The higher the metrics, the less power is used.

Comfortmaker heat pumps offer SEER ratings that range from 15.2 to 18.5 SEER2.

Models at the higher end of this SEER range are among the more energy-efficient options available on the market, suitable for those looking to maximize their energy savings in warmer climates.

The HSPF ratings for Comfortmaker heat pumps typically range from 8.1 to 9 HSPF2.

Heat pumps with higher HSPF ratings are particularly beneficial in regions with colder climates, as they ensure efficient heating while keeping energy costs low.

Some Comfortmaker heat pump models are Energy Star certified, which is also a mark of high energy efficiency.

Finally, advanced models of Comfortmaker heat pumps come equipped with variable-speed or two-stage compressors.

These compressors adjust their operation to match the exact heating and cooling needs of your home, which enhances energy efficiency by reducing electricity consumption during lower-demand periods.

TL;DR: With a SEER2 rating ranging between 15.2 to 18.5 and HSPF ratings ranging between 8.1 to 9, Comfortmaker scores average in terms of efficiency. 


How Do The Compressors Perform?

Comfortmaker typically utilizes advanced compressor technologies in their heat pumps, such as variable-speed and two-stage compressors.

Here's an overview of how these compressors perform:

Variable-speed compressors:

  • Efficiency:
    Variable-speed compressors are highly efficient because they can adjust their speed to match the exact heating or cooling demand. This means they operate at lower speeds for longer periods, providing more consistent temperatures and reducing energy spikes.
  • Noise level:
    These compressors are known for their quiet operation. Since they can run at lower speeds, the overall noise produced during operation is significantly reduced.
  • Humidity control:
    By running for longer cycles at lower speeds, variable-speed compressors are excellent at controlling humidity levels in the home, enhancing overall comfort.
  • Durability:
    Operating at lower speeds most of the time means less wear and tear on the compressor, potentially extending its lifespan.

Two-stage compressors:

  • Efficiency:
    Two-stage compressors offer improved efficiency over single-stage compressors. They operate at full capacity on hot summer days and at a reduced capacity when the demand is lower, saving energy.
  • Comfort:
    These compressors provide a more consistent indoor climate by minimizing temperature fluctuations. They adjust their output based on the current need, which can result in a more comfortable indoor environment.
  • Noise level:
    Similar to variable-speed compressors, two-stage compressors are quieter than traditional single-stage compressors, especially when operating in the lower stage.
  • Cost-effectiveness:
    While not as efficient as variable-speed models, two-stage compressors strike a balance between performance and cost, making them a more affordable option for improved efficiency.

TL;DR: Despite being a budget brand, Comfortmaker manages to offer variable speed compressors in their top models. The cheapest units offer single-stage compressors. Whereas, the midrange products offer dual-stage compressors.


Warranty Analysis – How Does Comfortmaker's Warranty Stack Up?

What’s the Warranty Coverage?

Comfortmaker offers a comprehensive warranty on their heat pumps. This includes the No Hassle Replacement limited warranty that’s available for:

  • 10 Years – Top-of-the-line products
  • 5 Years – Mid-tier products
  • 1 or 3 Years – Standard-level products

There’s also a standard warranty, which is a 10-year limited warranty. Some key components, such as heat exchangers, can have a longer limited warranty.

The best way to check for this is to look for specific details in the product description.

Is Registration Required For Full Warranty Coverage?

Yes, registration is required for full warranty coverage.

ACLAB note:

If the pump isn’t registered within a specified period (usually within 90 days of installation), you may end up with a reduced warranty period.

Comfortmaker offers an easy online registration process for their products.[1]

Are There Conditions And Restrictions?

Yes, there are some conditions and restrictions for warranty:

  • Installation requirements:
    The warranty is contingent on proper installation by a qualified technician. Improper installation can void the warranty.
  • Maintenance requirements:
    Regular maintenance by a professional contractor is required to keep the warranty valid. For example, regular inspection of the refrigerant lines is crucial to ensure optimal performance, and neglecting inspection can lead to warranty issues.
  • Split systems requirements:
    These systems must be matched with a Comfortmaker indoor coil or fan coil.
  • Transferability:
    Some warranties are transferable to a new homeowner, which can be a selling point, but this often requires specific procedures to be followed.
  • Replacement authorization:
    Before a unit is replaced, written authorization from the local Comfortmaker distributor technical service is required.

How Does It Measure Up To The Competition?

Comfortmaker's warranty is generally competitive within the HVAC industry.

Brands like Goodman, Trane, and Carrier also offer similar warranty terms, with variations in the length and coverage specifics.

TL;DR: The 10 year limited parts warranty offered by Comfortmaker is on par with the industry average. There is nothing extraordinary with the warranty this brand offers. 


Overview Of The Comfortmaker Heat Pump Models

The Comfortmaker heat pump lineup has three series.

Each is tailored to different customer needs and preferences, and each heat pump has a detailed manual that provides instructions for use and troubleshooting tips.

Here's a detailed look at these series. I'll briefly cover what you can expect from the models before going into more detail on each further below.

Ion Series

The Ion Series is Comfortmaker's premium offering, known for its high efficiency and advanced features.

This series is ideal for customers seeking the best in home comfort technology.
Models Included
  • Ion Variable-Speed Heat Pump (CVH8):
    The CVH8 stands out as the flagship model with a variable-speed compressor, allowing for subtle adjustments in operation to maintain optimal efficiency and comfort. Its quiet operation (as low as 56 decibels) and compatibility with the Ion System Control for Wi-Fi-enabled temperature management make it a top choice for tech-savvy homeowners.
  • Ion Two-Stage Heat Pump (C4H7T):
    This model operates primarily in a low stage for quieter and more efficient performance. It also supports dual fuel systems and remote access via the Ion System Control.
  • Ion Heat Pump (C4H5S):
    A high-efficiency model balances cost and performance. It's suitable for homeowners looking for a reliable heat pump without the premium price tag of the top-tier models.

TL;DR: The Ion is the top-of-the-line series offered by Comfortmaker. Models from this series offer the highest efficiency ratings and best features. 

Quiet Comfort Series

The QuietComfort heat pumps blend comfort management and reliable performance at a reasonable price.

It’s made up of one model: DULCURA. As the name suggests, one of the standout features of this pump is its low sound levels during operation, operating as quietly as 54 decibels.

The heat pump is designed for space-saving installation. It is ideal for multi-family use or homes with limited installation space.

TL;DR: Quiet Comfort is the middle-of-the-road series that balances price with efficiency rating and features.

Performance Series

The Performance Series is designed for economical and efficient heating and cooling, providing a budget-friendly option without compromising quality.

Models Included
  • Performance two-stage heat pump (N4H7T):
    This model provides smooth and consistent indoor temperatures. It's an affordable option for those who want an efficient heating mode and cooling mode without the higher cost of the premium models.
  • Performance heat pump (N4H5S) and (N4H5S*C):
    These two models are ENERGY STAR qualified and are a great choice for energy-conscious consumers looking for a balance between affordability and efficiency. The second of the two models (N4H5S*C model number) is best suited for coastal areas.

TL;DR: The Performance Series caters to the budget-conscious homeowners.


Popular Comfortmaker Heat Pumps Models Compared

Here’s a review of every heat pump Comfortmaker offers so you can choose the correct model for your home.

Model

SEER

Ton

Compressor Type

HSPF

CVH8

19

2 - 5

Variable

11

C4H7T

17

2 - 5

2-Stage

8.1

C4H5S

15.2

1.5 – 5

Single-Stage

8.1

DLCURA

18

2 - 5

Single-Stage

9.8

N4H7T

17

2 - 5

2-Stage

8.1

N4H5S/N4H5S***C

15.2

1.5 - 5

Single-stage

8.1

CVH8

Who is it best for?
  • It's best suited for those who prioritize energy savings, advanced features, and consistent indoor comfort

The CVH8 model from Comfortmaker is a top-tier heat pump known for its variable-speed compressor.

This makes it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking the highest efficiency and precise temperature control.

This heat pump has a high SEER Rating (up to 18.5 SEER2). It has one of the highest SEER ratings in the Comfortmaker range, which means top-notch cooling efficiency.

It’s also designed to operate quietly, which means optimal home comfort without noise disturbance.

Moreover, it has enhanced dehumidification, which improves indoor air quality.

Pros
  • High energy efficiency
  • Precise temperature control
  • Quiet operation
  • Excellent dehumidification capabilities
CONS
  • Higher upfront cost compared to standard models
  • Requires complex installation and maintenance

C4H7T

Who is it best for?
  • It’s best for moderate climates and those who want improved efficiency over standard models without the premium cost of variable-speed models.
The C4H7T is a two-stage heat pump, ideal for homeowners looking for a balance between cost and performance.

This heat pump has a two-stage compressor, which ensures reliable performance.

It also has good SEER2 (up to 17) and HSPF2 ratings (up to 8.1), which makes it suitable for moderate climates.

I noticed it operates quieter than single-stage models, providing a comfortable environment.

Finally, it has a dual fuel capability, so it can be paired with a furnace for optimized energy usage.

Pros
  • Two-stage compressor offers quiet performance
  • Dual fuel capability for versatile energy use
CONS
  • Not as efficient as variable-speed models
  • Limited advanced features compared to premium models

C4H5S

Who is it best for?
  • It’s best for homeowners who want a reliable and efficient heat pump without the higher investment of top-tier models.

The C4H5S model is a high-efficiency heat pump that strikes a balance between advanced features and affordability.

This heat pump has decent SEER2 (15.2) and HSPF2 ratings (8.1) for effective heating and cooling.

Compared to the above models, it’s a more affordable option while still maintaining good energy efficiency, which means less power used.

You can use it with a fan coil or pair it with a compatible furnace for dual fuel heat savings.
Pros
  • Good balance of efficiency and affordability
  • Durable and reliable performance
  • Suitable for a wide range of climates
  • Example text
CONS
  • Lacks some of the advanced features of higher-end models
  • Efficiency lower than top-tier models

DLCURA

Who is it best for?
  • It’s best for multi-family homes or places where installation space is limited, offering efficient heating and cooling in a smaller footprint.
The DLCURA, part of the QuietComfort series, is a compact heat pump designed for space-saving installation.

This heat pump has a compact design, ideal for limited-space installations without compromising on performance.

As part of the QuietComfort series, it ensures a peaceful indoor environment.

Finally, it provides good SEER2 (18) and HSPF2 (9.8) ratings for efficient operation. I have to give a special shoutout to the aesthetics.

It features a sleek design that blends well with various home exteriors.

Pros
  • Compact design ideal for limited spaces
  • Quiet operation, minimizing noise disturbance
  • Efficient performance in a smaller unit size
CONS
  • Not suitable for larger
  • Limited advanced technology features

N4H7T

Who is it best for?
  • It's best for those needing consistent indoor temperatures and efficient performance but with a limited budget.
The N4H7T is part of Comfortmaker's Performance series, and it offers a two-stage heat pump solution at an economical price point.

This also means it provides smooth and consistent heating and cooling.

This heat pump is a cost-effective solution with decent SEER2 (17) and HSPF2 (8.1) ratings.

This is another dual-fuel heat pump. You can combine it with a furnace for enhanced heating efficiency.

Pros
  • Economical choice with decent efficiency
  • Two-stage operation for consistent comfort
  • Durable and reliable for long-term use
CONS
  • Not as advanced as higher-end models
  • Not suitable for extreme climates

N4H5S/N4H5SC**

Who is it best for?
  • These models are best for homeowners looking for energy-efficient heat pumps at a more accessible price point, especially in coastal areas.

The N4H5S and N4H5SC models are part of the economical Performance series, with the N4H5S*C being a coastal version designed for corrosion resistance.

These heat pumps are Energy Star qualified, which means the energy efficiency meets or exceeds federal guidelines.

The N4H5S***C is specifically designed for coastal areas with added corrosion resistance.

Overall, these heat pumps ensure consistent and reliable heating and cooling for various home sizes.

Pros
  • Energy Star qualified for efficient operation
  • Cost-effective for budget-conscious homeowners
  • The coastal version offers added corrosion resistance
CONS
  • Lacking some advanced technologies
  • The coastal version has a higher cost

TL;DR: Comfortmaker does not have a huge line up of products making it easier for you to choose a unit that meets your budget, efficiency, and feature requirement.


HVAC Installation Options For Homeowners

Understanding installation fees, finding a reliable HVAC professional, and knowing some installation tips can make the process smoother and more efficient.

Guide To Installation Fees

Installation fees for HVAC systems, including heat pumps, can vary widely based on several factors:

  • Complexity of installation: The more complex the installation (e.g., retrofitting in an older home, ductwork modifications), the higher the cost.
  • Size and type of the system: Larger systems or those with advanced features like variable-speed technology typically cost more to install.
  • Geographical location: Labor costs can vary significantly depending on where you live. Urban areas or regions with a higher cost of living generally have higher installation fees.
  • Additional components: Additional components such as thermostats, air purification systems, or custom ductwork will add to the overall cost.
  • Average cost: You can expect installation costs to range from a few thousand dollars to several thousand, depending on the above factors.

TL;DR: The installation fees varies depending upon the size, location, labor cost, and the complexities involved with the installation.


How To Find a Reliable HVAC Professional

  • Certifications and licensing: Ensure the technician or company is licensed and certified. Look for certifications from organizations like NATE (North American Technician Excellence).
  • References and reviews: Check online reviews and ask for references. Word-of-mouth recommendations can also be valuable.
  • Estimates and quotes: Get detailed written estimates from multiple contractors to compare costs and understand what's included.
  • After-service support: Consider their warranty support and service availability for future maintenance or repairs.

TL;DR: The installation fees varies depending upon the size, location, labor cost, and the complexities involved with the installation.


Comfortmaker Heat Pump Installation Tips

  1. 1
    Proper sizing: Ensure the system is correctly sized for your home. An oversized or undersized unit can lead to inefficiency and increased wear.
  2. 2
    Quality ductwork: Good ductwork is essential for efficiency. Ensure that it's well-sealed and insulated, especially in unconditioned spaces.
  3. 3
    Optimal placement: The outdoor unit should be placed in a location where airflow is not obstructed and where noise won’t be a disturbance.
  4. 4
    Thermostat location: Install the thermostat away from direct sunlight, drafts, doorways, and windows to accurately measure the home's temperature.
  5. 5
    Regular maintenance: After installation, regular maintenance is vital to keeping the heat pump running efficiently. Discuss a maintenance schedule with your HVAC professional

What Do Other People Say About Comfortmaker Heat Pumps?

There aren’t many Comfortmaker user reviews, but based on the forums I checked, Comfortmaker heating systems get good reviews, which is a good sign, as most forum opinions tend to be negative.

“If you want something that’s reasonably priced with good quality and performance, go for a Comfortmaker DLCURA heat pump, V series furnace, and evaporator coil.”[2]
Reddit
“Comfortmaker is just fine. Their lower-end unit is essentially the same as a Carrier (who owns them). Their premium units are really nice with extra compressor protection & diagnostics and are very quiet.”[3]
HVAC-talk
“ComfortMaker and Grandair are ICP(International Comfort Products) brands. You are basically getting a relabeled Carrier. I'd take the ComfortMaker or Grandair over a Goodman.”[4]
Reddit

Tax Credit Benefits Explained

Specific Comfortmaker heat pump models, particularly those in the N4H4 family that meet specific efficiency criteria, are eligible for federal tax credits.

The federal tax credit program offers you $300 for buying and installing a highly efficient system. There are a few requirements for qualifying for the tax credit:

  • You must own the home and live in it. Rental properties don’t qualify.
  • The heat pump system must also be Energy Star certified and installed by a professional contractor.
  • If you buy a split system heat pump, it must be a minimum of 15 SEER and 8.5 HSPF.
  • If you buy a packaged heat pump, it must be a minimum of 14 SEER and 8 HSPF.
  • The system must be purchased and installed between January 1, 2017, and December 31, 2021.

You can apply for rebate on these Comfortmaker heat pump models:

  • CVH8: Up to $4,500 in rebates
  • C4H7T: Up to $4,500 in rebates
  • C4H5S: Up to $2,500 in rebates
  • DLCURA: Up to $4,500 in rebates
  • N4H7T: Up to 4,500 in rebates
  • N4H5S: Up to $2,500 in rebates

TL;DR: Depending upon the model and its efficiency rating, you can get significant benefit in tax rebates.


How Do Comfortmaker Heat Pumps Compare to Top Competitors?

Comfortmaker vs Air Temp Heat Pumps

Comfortmaker heat pumps boast a wide range of efficiency ratings, with SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) values ranging from 15.2 to 18.5 SEER2 and HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor) ratings from 8.2 to 11 HSPF2.

On the other hand, Air Temp offers models with up to 18 SEER and 9.0 HSPF.

While these figures are solid, they don't quite reach the upper-efficiency levels of Comfortmaker's best models.

Air Temp heat pumps have galvanized steel construction with a polyester urethane coat finish designed to resist corrosion.

This robust construction is complemented by a complete metal wrapper for added protection against external elements.

Comfortmaker also has reliable and durable units, thanks to the post-painted fin stock and the coated wire grille, which add an extra layer of protection against damage and corrosion.

Both brands offer advanced features like energy-efficient scroll compressors known for their quiet operation.

Air Temp's use of all-aluminum Micro-Channel ensures efficient heat transfer and corrosion resistance. Comfortmaker’s variable-speed and two-stage models, for example, offer nuanced control over heating and cooling, which can mean greater comfort and efficiency.

TL;DR: Air Temp is a budget brand like Comfortmaker, but its top model does not reach the efficiency levels of Comfortmaker.

Comfortmaker vs Mr. Cool Heat Pumps

A big difference between the two brands is their target audience.

Comfortmaker is typically marketed towards professional installation done by a contractor and is known for its reliability in a traditional HVAC system.

Mr Cool, on the other hand, has carved a niche in the DIY market, offering heat pumps designed for easy installation by homeowners.

Comfortmaker heat pumps have high SEER and HSPF ratings. Mr Cool heat pumps also generally offer competitive efficiency.

However, they might not always reach the higher efficiency levels of Comfortmaker's top models.

Comfortmaker heat pumps often come with advanced features like variable-speed and two-stage compressors, which provide nuanced control over temperature and can lead to increased comfort and efficiency.

While efficient, Mr Cool's heat pumps focus more on user-friendliness and ease of installation than advanced HVAC system technology.

However, they do offer features like Wi-Fi connectivity in some models, which can appeal to a tech-savvy audience.

TL;DR: Comfortmaker and Mr. Cool cater to two different markets. The former caters to those who which to have their units installed by professional. The latter caters to the DIY enthusiasts.

Comfortmaker vs Goodman Heat Pumps

Comfortmaker heat pumps offer a range of SEER ratings from 15.2 to 18.5 SEER2 and HSPF ratings from 8.2 to 11 HSPF2.

Goodman heat pumps typically feature SEER ratings ranging up to 24.5 SEER and HSPF ratings that are also competitive, though this can vary based on the specific model.

Goodman provides a broad selection of heat pump models, including those with advanced features like two-stage compressors and compatibility with smart home systems.

In terms of cost, Comfortmaker is generally positioned in the mid to high range in terms of pricing.

Goodman is often praised for its affordability, and it provides a cost-effective solution for those seeking reliable performance without a high price tag.

TL;DR: Goodman is a well established brand with a wide selection of heat pumps to choose from some of which can reach extreme efficiency of 24.5 SEER rating. Comfortmaker, however, is cheaper overall.


FAQs

Who makes a Comfortmaker heat pump?

Comfortmaker heat pumps are manufactured by International Comfort Products, LLC, a well-established company in the HVAC industry known for producing a range of heating and cooling products. They also own another popular heat pump brand, Carrier.

How long has Comfortmaker been around?

Comfortmaker has been around since the 1950s. This brand has been recognized by the HVAC industry for several decades.

How long does a Comfortmaker air conditioner last?

A Comfortmaker air conditioner typically lasts between 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance and installation. The lifespan can vary based on usage, climate, and regular servicing.

Summary | Is a Comfortmaker Heat Pump Right For You?

 3.9 out of 5 stars (3.9 / 5)


Comfortmaker offers a wide range of models to suit various budgets and requirements, from high-efficiency options with advanced features to cost-effective models.

Consider factors like climate, budget, desired efficiency, and home size when making your decision.

Overall, with its reputation for quality and a range of reliable choices, I recommend Comfortmaker as a brand worth exploring for your heating and cooling needs.

References: 

  1. https://productregistration2.icpusa.com/Public/Home?brand=icp
  2. https://www.reddit.com/r/hvacadvice/comments/165xzx0/anyone_have_advice_for_buying
  3. https://hvac-talk.com/vbb/threads/543812-need-opinions-of-Comfort-maker-units-PLEASE
  4. https://www.reddit.com/r/hvacadvice/comments/iu46o7/is_comfortmaker_any_good/ 
Was This Article Helpful?
YesNo

Josh Mitchell

Founder

Josh Mitchell
My name is Josh and I am obsessed with home appliances. From portable AC units to heaters and air purifiers, I enjoy testing, learning and using these devices to improve the air quality inside my family home.

My Favorite Home Appliance?

Midea U Shaped Window Air Conditioner

See Our Editorial Processes

Meet Our Team

Share Feedback