Air conditioners and fans remain the most viable commercial and private indoor cooling solutions. Most American homes like mine have a mix of both.
In this guide, I'll discuss which is more costly to run, which lasts longer, and other factors comparing fans and air conditioners.
Read on to discover if fans, AC, or a mix of both are best for your own home setup.
Key takeaways
Fan versus air conditioners – Which is best?
AC wins for cooling down the air
True AC units turn warm indoor air into cool air using a refrigerant.
So no matter the type you choose (central, portable, window, etc.), they provide comfortable, cool air to the entire house or one specific room, lowering its temperature.
In contrast, a fan doesn’t necessarily cool your room. In fact, it doesn’t do much to bring down the temperature of a space.
Instead, it circulates indoor air to minimize room stuffiness.
The bottom line here is that air conditioners lower the room's temperature, while fans circulate air.
ACLAB note:
You can't hook up any AC in your room and expect it to cool it down. It has to be sized properly (Read this guide). But if done right, even a small window AC can be highly effective at making the space more comfortable as compared to a large fan.
Choose fans for portability
One of the most valuable properties of a fan is that it can move anywhere you require them.
Some of the smallest fans can easily be placed on kitchen counters and even bedroom nightstands. I have a home desk fan that travels around my home with me each day.
Even taller designs can be shifted from one room to another without hassle.
On the other hand most air conditioning systems need to be permanently set up in the house. Even portable air conditioners require adequate venting through a window, making them more difficult to move than fans.
Of course, there are a few exceptions, such as camping air conditioners, but these are not powerful enough for cooling an entire room.
Related article: Top rated fans that cool like ACs
Power consumption & energy usage determine cost to run
All air conditioners need electricity to run. However, if you believe all AC units are expensive to run, think again!
Nowadays, many models come with higher energy efficiency. For example, some window ACs can only cost $35 a year to run, with a 15 EER.
Many air conditioner brands will provide these energy savings details along upfront.
ACLAB note:
Inverter ACs are especially energy efficient, as they use variable speed compressors to slightly adjust the temperature as needed, rather than cycling on and off.
Fans, however, consume very little energy. This is because their low-watt motors are usually highly efficient.
To calculate how much a fan would cost per year, I follow this simple formula:
(Wattage x Number of Hours Used) / 1000 x Price Per kWh
The average kWh in the US is around $0.13. So here's an example with a 45 watt tower fan:
(45 x 8 hours a day) / 1000 x $0.13 = $0.05 per day
Monthly = $1.50
Annually = $18.25
Both AC and fans use electricity and aren't free to run, but even the most budget conscious people can work either option into their spending by choosing energy efficient models.
Ease of installation & maintenance
Air conditioners have a complex and lengthy installation process when compared to fans.
However, many AC manufacturers are now making it a lot easier: they offer applicable installation kits alongside every tool you’ll need to set it up.
Though some units require the help of professional HVAC technicians to be installed, others are simple to install particularly the portable AC. Window ACs often require brackets but that can also be installed by yourself with a bit of effort.
Most fans, in contrast, only need a plug to perform. The exception here are wall mounted fans and ceiling fans.
Both fans and air conditioners require ongoing maintenance to ensure the best operation. This typically includes cleaning filters of dust and debris.
ACLAB note:
Window ACs are generally best suited for vertical sliding windows. For horizontal sliding windows and casement windows, you can either build a DIY contraption to fill the gaps or get a casement window AC.
For Portable ACs, you need to invest in a third party sealing kit for irregular windows.
Fans are far cheaper to procure and install
Fans are less expensive than air conditioners. You can buy a fan anywhere from $20 (desk fan) to $350 (ceiling fan) and more. Newer "bladeless fans" can cost upwards of $500.
Also, the installation cost of a fan varies from model to model. For example, the cost to install a desk fan is nothing; however, setting up a ceiling fan can cost you up to $300, including labor and parts.
Alternately, air conditioners can cost between $100 to $4000 and more. Similar to fans, the installation cost of ACs also varies from model to model.
For example, the cost of installing a centralized system ranges from $3300 to $7900. On the other hand, a portable AC or window AC can usually be installed for somewhere between $250 and $600.
Related article: Guide to portable AC running cost
Noise levels depends upon the type of appliance
The noise produced by air conditioners and fans depends on several things, including:

It's important to check the manufacturer's specifications regarding the noise level of a product, because they can vary widely across the board depending on these factors I've listed.
Overall, the noise level of fans usually ranges from 29 to 70 decibels based on the type of fan.
In contrast, air conditioners have noise levels between 31 to 83 decibels, also based on the style. Mini splits are the quietest where as Window ACs have an average noise rating of 55 dB. However, those with an inverter compressor are the quietest units reaching as low 40 dB.
You can lower some portable ACs by following our guidelines in this article.
Fans can typically last longer
Fans can last longer under normal running conditions. An average fan can last anywhere from 3-15 years.
On the contrary, premium fans can function adequately for up to 30 years, provided they have their maintenance.
Modern air conditioning systems can last anywhere between 15 to 20 years, while older ACs can survive between 10 to 12 years.
Moreover, the efficiency and health of air conditioners are based on many factors such as model type, proper maintenance, and care.
Pros & cons of using fans at home
Benefits
Drawbacks

Pros & cons of using air conditioners
Benefits
Drawbacks

ACLAB note:
ACs chill the air but are costly. Fans only circulate the existing air but are very cost effective.
If you are looking for something in between these two, try out evaporative coolers (aka ventless air conditioners). These appliances boast a large fan that blows air through a water soaked wick filter thus cooling the air down at a fraction of the running cost of an AC.
These have to be refilled with water, but a typical single refill can provide cool air for 6 hours.

Related article: Best evaporative coolers
FAQs
How do bladeless fans work?
Bladeless fans have a pedestal that includes an electric motor, which takes the air inside and transfers it to the tube. Thus, air circulates within the fan till it hits the slit within the tube.
Is the Dyson hot and cool fan worth it?
Yes, for a premium fan capable of serving its purpose exceptionally well, then the Dyson Hot and Cool fan is an excellent choice.
Can you use both AC and fan together?
You can. In fact, you should use your air conditioner along with your fan as doing so will help keep your energy bills lower every month, provided you use them properly.
Does fan mode in AC save electricity?
Yes, you can save power by using your AC on the fan mode. The electricity consumption on this mode is relatively lower primarily because it doesn’t rely on the compressor.



