Ashley Hearth Pedestal Stove

The Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P has an outstanding balance of aesthetic appeal and functional heating. Its capacity to evenly warm up a space as large as a 30 x 40 pole barn is impressive.

I prefer it over electric heaters, as I found the hot air it provides feels more natural and enveloping, creating a cozy atmosphere that's particularly enjoyable in cold weather.

I didn’t have any issues using the Ashley Hearth Pedestal Stove and I found the operation straightforward.

However, keep in mind it requires regular attention, such as loading wood and managing the fire.

If you want an active role in maintaining your heating system, this pole barn heater is a great choice.

Compared to the Mr. Heater Big Maxx (my second-best heating option), the Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P offers a more traditional and visually appealing experience, but it demands more active involvement in terms of fuel management and maintenance.

The cost-effectiveness of wood as a fuel, especially in areas where it's readily available, is a significant advantage.

The Ashley Hearth meets the EPA's strict wood heating certification, meaning that you can count on it to burn more efficiently and cleanly than non-certified models. 

However, you’ll have to use this heating system in spaces with proper ventilation, which also means you’ll have to install a chimney system if you don’t have one for safety and effective operation.

Mr. Heater Big Maxx

The Mr. Heater F260550 Big Maxx is a standout for its robust heating capacity, making it an excellent choice for heating large barns efficiently. It has 50,000 BTUs, which can heat up to 1250 square feet.

I often recommend this model for those seeking flexibility, as this heater gives me two mounting options. I can choose between vertical or horizontal venting thanks to the powered exhaust.

Moreover, I love that you don’t need to be next to it to change the settings. I could control the heater from outside the building, thanks to the thermostat and AC terminals.

Its operation on natural gas is a significant advantage over other heaters on this list. I found the use more automated and less labor-intensive compared to wood-fired models.

In other words, it requires significantly less work than the Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P.

This is a great choice if you want a set-and-forget type of heating system.

Plus, I could easily adjust and maintain a comfortable temperature within the barn, even though it had a high ceiling.

I also appreciated the materials used and the build quality of the Mr. Heater Big Maxx.

It’s designed to withstand the rigors of barn environments and ensure durability over time.

However, keep in mind it requires a minimum 8 foot clearance from floor to base of the heater, which leads me to the complex installation.

I needed professional assistance, which is an important factor to consider.

Mr. Heater Portable Propane

The Mr. Heater F271390 stands out for its portability and quick heating capability.

Its forced-air design means it can rapidly warm up a space, making it invaluable during particularly cold weather.

However, forced-air systems can circulate dust, which is a downside if you plan to operate it in sensitive environments.

I found it's especially beneficial in a pole barn setting where quick temperature adjustments are often needed. The ease of use is another significant advantage.

Unlike the Mr. Heater Big Maxx, it requires no complex installation. It is a practical choice if you want a straightforward, plug-and-play type of heater.

Another advantage is that the Mr. Heater F271390 offers greater flexibility in terms of placement and is more suited for immediate, targeted heating.

However, it may fall short in heating very large rooms as efficiently.

The reliance on propane meant I had to be mindful of fuel levels, which can be a minor inconvenience.

This is one of the quietest pole barn heaters I've ever used. The manufacturer claims it's 50% quieter than other propane heaters.

While I didn't measure the noise levels, I agree it's very quiet, which is handy if you plan to use it in a man cave or a garage.

This pole barn heater comes in several versions, from 38,000 BTUs to 400,000 BTUs, so you can easily choose the size that can heat your space best.

Mr. Heater Ceiling Mount

The Mr. Heater F272800 ceiling mount is a great choice for those who want to maximize their space.

I loved that its ceiling-mounted design frees up floor space, making it ideal for barns where space is at a premium.

I had my reservations about the heat output due to its small size.

However, despite its compact size, it provides ample warmth, suitable for a variety of barn sizes. It’s suitable for spaces up to 1,000 square feet and in spaces with 12 to 15 foot ceilings.

I liked that the installation process is relatively simpler compared to larger furnace models, which is great if you don’t want to worry about a complex setup.

However, its fixed position means that once installed, it lacks the portability of standalone units.

This natural gas model doesn't need electricity to run, which means you can use it even during a power outage.

Compared to Dr. Heater DR966, the Mr. Heater F272800 is a more discreet, space-efficient solution with less flexibility in positioning and movement.

Related article: Heating options for power outage

Dr. Heater Hardwired Shop Heater

The Dr. Heater DR966 is an excellent choice for smaller barn spaces where efficient and reliable warm air is needed.

It's another compact-sized heater but has effective heating capability, making it ideal for areas with limited space.

Plus, the eight-inch fan circulated hot air inside the buildings but was quiet.

I found the installation process to be straightforward, which gives it a significant advantage over more complex gas or wood-fired heaters.

The adjustable thermostat is a useful feature. It allowed me to get precise temperature control, which enhances comfort and efficiency.

However, I found it's not as effective in very large spaces. Moreover, being dependent on electricity might restrict its use in barns with limited electrical access.

Keep this in mind if you plan to use it in more remote locations or where electrical infrastructure is not robust.

Compared to the Ashley Hearth AW1120E-P, the Dr. Heater DR966 offers a more modern, convenient solution but lacks the larger area coverage and the traditional charm of a wood-fired model.

What is the safest heat source for a barn?

The safest heat source for a barn is typically an electric heater, especially models with built-in safety features like automatic shut-off and overheat protection.

Does the color of the roof on pole barn affect heat?

Yes. Darker colors, like black or dark brown, tend to absorb more heat from the sun and cold from the snow.

Lighter colors, such as white or light gray, reflect more sunlight, helping to keep the interior of the barn cooler.

Do pole barns need ventilation?

Yes, pole barns need ventilation. Proper ventilation ensures a healthier environment, particularly if the barn is used for housing livestock or storing hay, where moisture and ammonia can build up.

It also helps in maintaining the structural integrity of the barn by preventing mold, mildew, and rot.