“If you make a purchase using our provided links, we may receive a commission. Learn more here.
Quick Guide - Trane
My Opinion
When it comes to heat pumps, Trane knows what they are doing. Still, that doesn't stop them from performing quality control testing on each and every heat pump before passing it on to the consumer. For top energy efficiency, Trane is a go-to brand.
4.6
Overall Score
Reliability
4.5
Performance
4.5
Energy Efficiency
4.6
Warranty
4.7
Value for Money
4.5
Upsides
Downsides
The Trane company dates back to 1885 when James Trane started developing an innovative low-pressure heat pump system.
It wasn’t until 1931 that the company began focusing on other HVAC products, like Trane air conditioners, whole-home air cleaners, and humidifiers.
Heating has always been the main focus of this company, which is why you'll see it listed as the first category on the Trane website.
For this reason, as well as others, I've come to trust Trane when the temperatures begin to drop.
Here’s a quick breakdown of my favorite Trane units for heating (as well as one to avoid):
Quick guide to Trane heat pumps
Trane XV20i Variable Speed Heat Pump
If you're willing to spend the money, I highly recommend the XV20i. This is by far the company's best heat pump, and not just because it's built with a variable-speed compressor that enhances efficiency to 20 SEER.
In addition to impressive energy savings, there’s a lot you can expect from the XV20i, like precise temperature control, quiet operation, and extreme durability for years to come.
Trane XR15
If the cost of the XV20i isn't something you can swing, consider the Trane XR15 instead. This much cheaper alternative is an excellent choice if you want to stay warm in the winter without consuming too much energy, all for the best value.
The XR15 has a 15-16 SEER rating and a highly-efficient HSPF of 9.5. My only complaint is the loud operation when the heat pump is working at the highest setting.
Trane XL15
The Trane XL15 heat pump is a device that is perfectly capable of heating your home, but it has a few flaws. First off, it's extremely low on energy efficiency compared to other Trane models, including the similar XR15.
All XL devices from Trane are designed to be budget-friendly, so the components aren't nearly as durable. I think it's worth spending a few hundred more on a more efficient, more durable heat pump from Trane, like the XR14 or the XR15.
Trane has been a leader in the HVAC industry for quite some time now, and the company’s heat pumps are well-respected for their efficiency, value, and reliable operation.
I’ve used my fair share of Trane heat pump units over the years, and just as the company claims, Trane systems get the job done when it comes to heating my home.
In this guide, I’ll cover all the top-selling Trane products for heating your home efficiently and effectively.
Trane heat pump review – My opinion on the units
After testing several Trane products and reading countless reviews of all Trane series, I have mostly good things to say about this brand and only a few minor complaints.
Pros and cons of buying a Trane heat pump
The good
The bad
How much do Trane heat pumps cost?
The cost of Trane heating and cooling systems depends on the model you’ve chosen, its size, and the exact labor and installation fees charged by your local Trane dealer.
When browsing the Trane website, most products are priced with the installation fee included in the cost, so don’t freak out too much.
However, it’s still a good idea to confirm ahead of time whether or not the price you see includes the installation fee to avoid any billing surprises.
It’s also important to note that some HVAC contractors charge an extra fee to dispose of your old HVAC equipment.
The norm is about $100, but it’s totally worth it to have a professional handle the disposal of your old equipment for you.
Pricing by model & size
Here’s a quick breakdown of expected costs (including installation and disposal fees) based on popular Trane heat pump models.
I’ve also included the average SEER for each model to give you a better idea of potential energy savings.
Trane Model | SEER Rating | Expected Cost |
|---|---|---|
XR14 | Up to 14.8 | $5,400 - $7,400 |
XR15 | Up to 17 | $6,800 - $9,200 |
XL17i | Up to 17.2 | $8,800 - $12,400 |
XV18 | Up to 18 | By quote only |
XV19 | Up to 19.5 | By quote only |
XV20i | Up to 20 | By quote only |
You’ll notice that some model prices are only available by quote from your local dealer.
These heat pumps are larger and more complex, so Trane can only give a quote after seeing your current system and evaluating installation complexity.
Heat Pump Model | Home Size | Cost (Unit Only) | Cost + Install |
|---|---|---|---|
XV20i Variable Speed | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $5700 – $8000 | $10500 – $14500 |
XV19 Variable Speed | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $5600 – $7900 | $9500 – $13500 |
XV18 Variable Speed | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $5400 – $7700 | $9000 – $13000 |
XL18i Two-Speed | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $5100 – $7400 | $8000 – $11500 |
XR17 | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $4600 – $5700 | $7200 – $10400 |
XL16i | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $4500 – $5600 | $6800 – $9600 |
XR16 Low Profile | 1200 – 3000 sq. ft. | $4300 – $5500 | $6800 – $9600 |
XR16 | 1000 – 3000 sq. ft. | $4250 – $5400 | $10000 – $13400 |
XR15 | 900 – 3000 sq. ft. | $3500 – $5000 | $5200 – $7600 |
XR14 | 900 – 3000 sq. ft. | $3300 – $4800 | $5400 – $7400 |
What makes Trane heat pumps popular?
Trane has always been focused on innovation, constantly offering new features to make the company’s heat pumps stand out among competitor brands.
There’s a long list of features and functions that make Trane heat pumps so popular, including:
ComfortLink™ II communicating control board
This smart thermostat makes it possible to optimize your temperature and humidity levels from the wall-mounted control panel.
Through the ComfortLink II, you can program and remotely control your device.
Unique refrigerant-cooled inverter drive
The inverter drive powers the compressor and controls communication between components to optimize heating efficiency.
Climatuff® variable speed compressor
This technology allows the Trane system to adjust automatically, avoiding temperature fluctuations in your home.
Compressor sound insulator
Many heating HVAC systems operate at a loud volume, but not this one; it’s all thanks to the Trane sound insulator system.
All-aluminum spine fin™ coil
Most heating and AC units use copper or aluminum coils that tend to corrode and leak over time.
With Trane HVAC systems, the aluminum coil enhances airflow while resisting corrosion and leakage.
WeatherGuard™ II top (XV20i Only)
The XV20i is designed with a durable polycarbonate top to protect the heat pump from potential damage.
DuraTuff™ rustproof basepan
Most basepans corrode, crack, or rust with time and use. Trane prevents this from happening with its improved rustproof basepan design.
Full-sided louvered panels
Trane heating and cooling systems are built with galvanized steel panels to protect the internal components while maintaining airflow.
Powder-paint finish & WeatherGuard
Compared to other brands, Trane offers virtually indestructible heating systems thanks to each product’s powder-paint finish.
Impressive warranty policies
All of Trane’s air conditioners and heat pumps come with a warranty ranging from 1 to 20 years with the option to extend the policy from 5 years to a lifetime warranty.
Warranty analysis – How does it stack up?
The Trane warranty is among the best in the heating and air conditioner market. At a minimum,
Trane customers get a 10-year limited warranty that covers most parts, but not labor or the refrigerant.
For some XL and XV models, the limited warranty coverage is extended to 12 years for the compressor.
Trane also gives you the option to purchase an extended warranty in 5, 10, or 12-year increments to include additional coverage on certain parts and labor.
Overview of Trane heat pump models
Trane currently offers 3 heat pump series to choose from, ranging in price, energy efficiency, and size. These series include the XV, XR, and XL.
Trane XV heat pumps
Trane’s XV series of heat pumps is designed to be the most energy-efficient, using the latest technologies in the HVAC industry.
Because of their energy efficiency, these units tend to have a higher upfront cost.
However, you won’t see any major spikes in your utility bills thanks to the high SEER ratings and Energy Star certifications of XV devices.
Trane XL heat pumps
The XL line strikes a balance between value and efficiency. It offers better features than the XR series and is more affordable than the XV series.
The XL16i and XL18i models offer two-stage cooling and heating, providing better comfort control and energy savings.
If you prioritize reliability and reasonable pricing, the XL series is worth considering.
Trane XR heat pumps
The XR line is the most budget-friendly. While some products in this series may be less efficient, they provide a cost-effective option for those seeking basic features.
The XR14 and XR16 are popular options.
You'll find the Spine Fin Coil in XL and XV series heat pumps but not in the less innovative XR series, so consider that before purchasing.
The most popular Trane heat pumps models compared
Trane has several models to choose from, ranging from the budget-friendly XL series to the insanely efficient XV series.
Below, I’ve laid out all the details of each heat pump that Trane currently offers to help homeowners with the buying process.
Heat Pump Model | SEER | Ton | Compressor Type | HSPF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
XV20i Variable Speed | 20 | 2 – 5 | Variable speed | 10 |
XV19 Variable Speed | 19.5 | 2 – 5 | Variable speed | 12 |
XV18 Variable Speed | 18 | 2 – 5 | Variable speed | 10 |
XL18i Two-Speed | 18 | 2 – 5 | Two-stage | 9.5 |
XR17 | 17.25 | 2 – 5 | Two-stage | 9.6 |
XL16i | 20 | 2 – 5 | Single-stage | 10 |
XR16 Low Profile | 17 | 2 – 5 | Single-stage | 10 |
XR16 | 17 | 1.86 – 5 | Single-stage | 9.6 |
XR15 | 16 | 1.5 – 5 | Single-stage | 9.5 |
XR14 | 14 | 1.5 – 5 | Single-stage | 8.2 |
XR15 & XR15 low profile
Main features:
The XR15 and the XR15 Low Profile Heat Pump are both great options for homeowners who don’t want to spend too much upfront but also want to see savings on their winter utility bills.
Both models are Energy Star qualified and have received countless 5-star Trane heat pump reviews.
The only downside is the somewhat noisy operation; the pump operates around 70 decibels when blowing at full force.
XL15
Main features:
Similar to the XR15, Trane’s XL15 is a single-speed heat pump that’s great for maintaining consistent temperatures in your home.
If you live in a moderate climate that doesn’t experience overly drastic temperature swings, this is an excellent choice.
The only real difference between the XR and XL15 models is size. The XL15 has much smaller dimensions, so if you're limited on space, this is a great alternative.
XR14
Main features:
In terms of aesthetics, the XR14 is almost identical to the XR15. The upfront cost is slightly cheaper, but the projected energy savings are also about 10% lower.
This heat pump is perfect for those who need a reliable solution to heating in an area that doesn’t often get colder than 30 degrees Fahrenheit.
If you live in a location that frequently dips below freezing, I recommend a more powerful heating solution with a multi-stage compressor.
XV17
Main features:
Trane's XV17 is the perfect option for homeowners who want a variable-speed heating solution that's energy efficient.
Variable-speed compressors are better for drastic temperature dips, so this is one to consider if your location experiences extreme cold.
For slightly more energy efficiency and more energy savings, you’ll also want to consider the XV18 or XV19.
They share the same design as the XV17, but the higher SEER rating equates to more savings (and greater tax credits from the government).
XL17i
Main features:
While the XV17 features a variable-speed design, the compressor of the XL17i is designed with 2 speeds.
For this reason, the upfront cost is slightly cheaper. However, you still get the benefits of a dual-speed compressor to help maintain indoor temperatures.
XV20i
Main features:
Last but not least is Trane’s XV20i with variable-speed compressor.
This is the company’s most energy-efficient heat pump with an impressive 20.5 SEER rating.
If you value efficiency above all else, this is the one for you.
HVAC installation options for homeowners
Most contractors and HVAC companies list prices including the cost of the unit as well as installation.
However, the final price can vary based on your location, the specific model you’ve chosen, and the professional’s level of expertise.
Before actually installing your new heat pump, you can expect the installer to perform a home visit.
After this visit, you should be provided with a detailed cost estimate for the upcoming job of installing your Trane.
There are a lot of factors that can influence the final cost of the job, including:
What do other people say about Trane heat pumps?
So far, I’ve been raving about Trane and each product’s ability to efficiently provide heat to a home, even when the temperatures reach 0 degrees Fahrenheit.
But don’t just take my word for it!
Here are several statements from happy Trane customers who posted on reputable sites like Consumer Affairs, Trane.com, and Consumer Reports.
These reviewers recommend Trane for a variety of reasons.
“My Trane HVAC system was 17 years old and stilling working fine… I received great service from my old unit, 9 hurricanes, many severe storms and never once has my Trane failed to function and operate flawlessly. If anyone asks I always recommend a Trane.”
-Charles from Wilmington, NC
“Our bills have already dropped since install. We never hear this or the Hyperion air handler. Super efficient for both heat and air. Love it so far.”
-Trane XV20i Customer
“My old heat pump before this, was also a Trane. It lasted 25 years. It ran smooth till it just died. Wonderful quality. New Trane is quiet and works well.”
-Trane XR15 Customer
Tax credit benefits for Trane
Both federal and state governments are rewarding people for turning to more energy-efficient alternatives for heating and cooling their homes.
Basically, the government is incentivizing us to go green, and what better way to do that than by sending out checks in the mail?!
By upgrading to one of Trane's more energy-efficient heat pump systems with a high SEER rating, you could get up to $2,650 back in annual tax credits after the product is installed.
Of course, not every unit will put money back into your pocket. If you want to make the most of this program, opt for select models with high-efficiency ratings, like the XV20i.
You can find more information on available tax credits and rebates by visiting Trane’s website.
Related article: HVAC federal tax credit – Which systems are eligible?
How do Trane heat pumps compare to top competitors?
Trane Vs Carrier heat pumps
Both Trane and Carrier are widely respected HVAC companies, and they have been for decades.
Both make great residential systems that are built to last, and both companies believe that high efficiency is an important quality when it comes time for heating season.
On average, Trane pumps offer a higher SEER.
They are, therefore, more energy efficient (unless you're considering the Carrier Infinity line of pumps, which has an impressive SEER that even Trane can't beat).
Carrier systems tend to be slightly cheaper, but not by much.
However, you should also note that Carrier repairs and replacement parts cost less on average, so if price is your main concern, definitely consider going with the Carrier brand.
Trane is the better choice for homeowners who value smart features, like improved thermostat technology.
To top it off, Trane pumps offer quiet operation, a longer warranty, and higher overall satisfaction ratings from past customers.
Trane Vs Goodman heat pumps
Goodman is another brand to consider if you're in the market for an Energy Star-qualified heat pump.
This brand has built a solid reputation for delivering reliable products that can withstand 10-15 years of use.
In terms of quality, Trane and Goodman are very similar. Both companies use quality parts and durable components, but Goodman tends to charge less upfront.
However, Goodman systems aren’t known to offer the same high efficiency as Trane, so you might see an increase in utility bills.
Overall, a Goodman HVAC system is 100% worth the money, especially for those with less to spend upfront.
Installation and repair costs also tend to be less for Goodman products compared to Trane.
Trane Vs Lennox heat pumps
Lennox heat pumps are some of the most energy-efficient on the market; the most efficient Lennox model has a 26 SEER, which even Trane can’t beat.
Many popular Lennox models have smart features like WiFi connectivity and Alexa/Google Home compatibility.
Operating costs are affordable, and many homeowners even claim Lennox to be the most budget-friendly brand when it comes to heating a home.
Compared to Trane, Lennox repairs can be quite costly and frustrating to deal with.
There have been complaints about the incompatibility of generic parts, which isn’t the case for Trane customers.
How energy efficient are Trane products?
When it comes to operating costs as well as helping the environment, there are two criteria you need to look into:
- 1Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF):
This metric tells you what to expect from your system during the heating season. The HSPF is a consideration of the heat pump’s ability to convert electrical energy into heat, and the higher the HSPF, the better. - 2Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER):
SEER is the measurement of cooling performance during the summer months. Heat pumps also serve as air conditioners, so you need to consider both the heating and cooling capacities. SEER ratings typically fall between 13 and 22 (a higher rating means better efficiency).
Compared to other brands, Trane offers average marks regarding efficiency.
Most of the company's newer products are extremely energy efficient, with the highest SEER ratings, like the XV20i.
Still, they also carry cheaper alternatives that aren't nearly as efficient, like the XR14.
How do the compressors perform?
Compressor performance is one of the main reasons for Trane’s popularity.
The compressor of a heat pump is responsible for moving refrigerant through the system, making it an important component of all air handlers.
The brand’s compressors are durable, well-built, and powerful, and Trane gives customers 3 options for compressor types:
Type | Detail |
|---|---|
Single-Stage Compressor | Also called one-stage compressors, these systems are cheaper upfront but have to work much harder to cool or heat your home. Because of this, single-stage compressor systems like the XR14 and XR15 are less energy efficient, leading to higher utility bills. |
Two-Stage Compressor | Two-stage compressor systems operate at two speeds. Rather than operating at full capacity 100% of the time, these can switch between lower and higher compression speeds to save on energy. |
Variable-Speed Compressor | A variable-speed HVAC system offers impressive temperature control that a single or 2-stage compressor cannot. To maintain proper temperatures, this compressor takes into account the humidity levels, outdoor temperatures, and run time. Trane heat pumps with the TruComfort system are built with variable-speed compressors, like the XV20i. |
FAQs
Who makes Trane heat pumps?
Trane was purchased by American Standard back in 1984. Even though American Standard is technically Trane’s parent company, all products - including heat pumps - are still produced and sold under the Trane brand.
What is the lifespan of a Trane heat pump?
The average lifespan of a Trane heat pump is 15 years, but with proper maintenance, your Trane air product could operate for as long as 20 years.
How do I know if my Trane is a heat pump or mini split?
The easiest way to determine if your Trane system is a heat pump or mini split is to activate the heating mode on your thermostat. Once the heating system has been triggered, check the exterior unit; if it’s blowing air, then it’s considered a heat pump.
What is the minimum temperature for a Trane heat pump?
Trane HVAC systems are designed to work in all seasons and climates. The brand’s more efficient heat pump systems can handle temperatures as low as 0 degrees Fahrenheit for average-sized homes.
Summary | So, are Trane heat pumps any good?
[usr 4.6]
Trane has cultivated a great reputation among homeowners looking to stay warm, and there’s a reason for that - Trane heat pumps are indeed good!
Whether you’re looking for smart thermostats, low noise levels, or efficient operation, Trane has you covered.
I recommend the XV20i, especially considering you can get up to $2,650 in tax credits thanks to this model’s efficiency.
If the XV20i doesn’t work with your budget, consider the XR15 instead.
It’s still extremely efficient, offering up to 38% in energy savings, but its upfront cost won’t break the bank.
